Bank consolidation is choking off entrepreneurship in the Midwest Imagine a small-town entrepreneur brimming with innovative ideas but thwarted by the absence of a supportive local bank willing to take a chance on their dream. This scenario is becoming increasingly common as the American banking landscape shrinks, a trend accelerated by the Great Recession and well-meaning regulations like the Dodd-Frank Act. The recent collapse of Silicon Valley Bank has reignited concerns over banking consolidation — a trend that, if left unchecked, endangers the very heartbeat of America’s economic dynamism: its entrepreneurs. The trend is stark: Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation data shows the number of FDIC-insured banking institutions has halved from 9,200 in 2003 to about 4,700 as of last year. This severe decline is not just a statistic; it has profound effects on the economy, particularly on the dreams of aspiring entrepreneurs nationwide. Our recent study sheds light on the increasing concentration within the banking industry in the U.S. Midwest and unveils a troubling decline in entrepreneurship as banking consolidation gains momentum. The growing concentration of banks could lead to reduced accessibility and affordability, ultimately resulting in a downturn in the region’s financial and entrepreneurial endeavors. The rapid advancements in automation and artificial intelligence are changing industries and altering the employment landscape. However, entrepreneurship remains a strong counterforce. Armed with innovative ideas and a willingness to take calculated risks, entrepreneurs are the driving force behind creating new opportunities that shape our economy. Every job that exists today is a testament to someone who seized an opportunity and submitted a new business application. The industry giants, such as Microsoft, Apple and Amazon, were all once mere concepts brought to life by determined entrepreneurs. The Federal Reserve’s vice chair for supervision said new definitions around community development activities and the ability for banks to invest outside their immediate assessment areas could be a boon to Native Americans and their communities. Critics might argue that larger banks are more stable and efficient. However, efficiency should not come at the cost of local economies’ diversity and health. With their local ties and understanding of unique community needs, community banks and credit unions are crucial in this ecosystem. They often provide more personalized services and are more likely to take risks on local ventures, unlike their larger counterparts. Addressing and reversing the current trajectory of bank consolidation presents a formidable challenge that demands coordinated efforts from all levels of government. At the heart of this endeavor lies the need to carefully evaluate and determine the most effective policies to put into action. Policymakers must engage in thoughtful deliberation, considering measures that can strike a balance between fostering a robust and stable banking sector and preserving the vitality of small community banks. Policymakers should explore ways to incentivize community banking, such as offering tax breaks for small-business loans or reassessing the regulatory burdens that hamper the competitiveness of small banks. They can learn from international models and encourage the development of local financial technology initiatives to revitalize the entrepreneurial ecosystem in a two-pronged approach. Regularly monitoring the impact of their initiatives and making necessary adjustments is imperative for policymakers. Evaluating how these incentives and regulatory changes influence small-business growth, job creation and economic development will be instrumental in refining the approach over time. The dreams of America’s entrepreneurs must not fade away with the consolidation of its banks. Our collective future hinges on our ability to create an environment where new business ideas can find the support they need to grow. As policymakers consider new regulations in the banking sector, they must do so with an eye to preserving and nurturing the entrepreneurial spirit that has long been the cornerstone of American innovation and prosperity.
This content was originally published here.
